Document title: Actions to Clean up PEPS     Document details     Comments     Help with document reviews

[ ¤1] Status and Actions, PEPs-under-review cleanup

[ ¤2] K. Schopmeyer, 9 Feb 2009

[ ¤3] Summary:

[ ¤4] Done

  1. [ ¤5] PEPs Archived and bugs defined for history: 220, 270,276,50, 265
  2. [ (k_schopmeyer) Add PEP 169 to this list.
    ¤6]     PEPs to give to steering committee: 3,333, 173
  3. [ ¤7] PEPsApproved earlier so moved and archived:  52, 187, 90, 91,229,248,313, 138, 193, 195, 214,
  4. [ ¤8] PEPs archived: 117, 190, 196, 268, 290, 310
  5. [ ¤9] PEPs deleted: 271

[ ¤10]  PEPS Previously Agreed

[ ¤11] PEPs For which we need to keep history but want to archive

  1. [ ¤12] PEP 220 - Archived, marked as superceeded and bug 8382 created to replace it. Link in bug to PEP created comments that bug 8382 superceeded this PEP. Link in bug to PEP created.
  2. [ ¤13] PEP 270 - Archived, marked as superceeded and bug 8383 create to replace it.  Link from bug to PEP created.
  3. [ ¤14] PEP 276 Moved to archive. Marked as deferred. Bug 377 updated to link to the archived version of this PEP.
  4. [ ¤15] PEP 50 - Moved to Archive. WHAT SHOULD STATUS BE.  The current one has approved but that is not really consistent with the concept that approved things in archive are really just copies of the approved PEPS??

[ ¤16] PEPs to give to Steering Committee (No Action)

  1. [ ¤17] PEP 3
  2. [ ¤18] PEP 333

[ ¤19] PEPS that need to be moved to approved and archived

  1. [ ¤20] PEP 52 - Moved to approved.and archived as approved. DONE
  2. [ ¤21] PEP 187 - Moved to approved.and archived as approved. DONE Could not find ballot.  Moved to approved and archived.
  3. [ ¤22] PEP 90 - Moved to Approved and archived. DONE
  4. [ ¤23] PEP 91 - Moved to Approved and archived. DONE
  5. [ ¤24] PEP 229 - Marked approved and moved and archived. DONE. Cannot find ballot for this approval but this was concept, not functional pep so maybe no ballot.  Notes made in comment to pep.  WHOOPS. Update noted on 20 April 2006 so maybe ballots in 2006
  6. [ ¤25] PEP 248 - Moved to approved and archived. PEP status internal set to Approved. Note that no ballot found for this one.
  7. [ ¤26] PEP 313 - Moved to Archive (put approved and ballot number into PEP) and archived.  It was approved in Ballon 148

[ ¤27] Specific PEPS from last review

[ ¤28] NOTE:  Blue text is the original comments from the review.

  1. [ ¤29] PEP 117 - No clear direction for this work. Archive. Done
  2. [ ¤30] PEPs 138 & 193 - 138 approved ballot 75  , 193 approve and move 1.3.  either find ballot or reballot.
  3. [ ¤31] PEP 173 - Take to steering committee.   Archive for them. DONE. Moved to archive but status left as draft. TODO: Change Status??
  4. [ ¤32] PEP 190 - archive.  Put note in bug 493 pointing to archived pep. DONE. Archived and hyperlink added to bug 493
  5. [ ¤33] PEP 195- Not approved ballot 81. ballot 84 version 1.6 failed.  Put on search for approval list. Approved by steering commitee ballot.  It was implemented so we move this one to approved. DONE. Moved to Approved with not in PEP. Archived as approved.
  6. [ ¤34] PEP 196 - Steering Committee
  7. [ ¤35] PEP 214 - Ballot search for approval.  DONE Approved Ballot 91. Marked approved, moved to approved and to archive
  8. [ ¤36] PEP 265 - Move to bugzilla and archive. DONE Moved to archive and marked as deferred. Bug 8388 created pointing back to the bug.
  9. [ ¤37] PEP 268 - Archive as not done. Marked as withdrawn. DONE
  10. [ ¤38] PEP 271 - This was duplicate so we really need to delete, not archive. Deleted as duplicate. No useful info in the deleted document. DONE
  11. [ ¤39]

    [ ¤40] PEP 290 - archive.  Archived and marked as deferred. DONE

  12. [ ¤41]

    [ ¤42] PEP 297 - active.  .4.1 approved ballot 132. so status updated to reflect approved.

  13. [ ¤43]

    [ ¤44] PEP 299 - active

  14. [ ¤45]

    [ ¤46] PEP 300 - active

  15. [ ¤47]

    [ ¤48] PEP 304 - active

  16. [ ¤49]

    [ ¤50] PEP 309 - active

  17. [ ¤51]

    [ ¤52] PEP 310 - Send note to bart as to what we should do. DONE.  Response was that this work has been superceeded.  Therefore, for this PEP we should simply archive as withdrawn. DONE

  18. [ ¤53]

    [ ¤54] PEP 312 - action Judy.

  19. [ ¤55]

    [ ¤56] PEP 317 - active

  20. [ ¤57]

    [ ¤58] PEP 318 - active

  21. [ ¤59]

    [ ¤60] PEP 320 - active

  22. [ ¤61]

    [ ¤62] PEP 324 - active

  23. [ ¤63]

    [ ¤64] PEP 327 - active

  24. [ ¤65]

    [ ¤66] PEP 334 - active

  25. [ ¤67]

    [ ¤68] PEP 335 - active

  26. [ ¤69]

    [ ¤70] PEP 339 - active

  27. [ ¤71]

    [ ¤72] PEP 340 - active.  There are issues between the code and PEP.  We need to discuss this one.

[ ¤73]